Ending Affirmative Action May Not Produce a More Academically Gifted Student Body

On June 29, 2023, the Supreme Court of the United States restricted the ability of colleges and universities to use race-conscious admission policies. The decision is rooted in the premise that using race in admissions processes unfairly bars more academically qualified students from college and university enrollment.

However, a new study from Cornell University has challenged this theory, providing insight into how the ban on affirmative action impacts student diversity in higher education. According to the study’s findings, removing race data from universities’ previously developed applicant-ranking algorithms causes a significantly less diverse top-ranked pool of applicants without meaningfully increasing the academic merit of that group.

The study authors created an AI admissions algorithm for an unnamed university and trained it on previous admissions decisions. They then retrained the algorithm without race-related data. Over half of the top-ranking applicant pool pulled by the first algorithm consisted of students from underrepresented racial backgrounds, but the second algorithm produced a top-ranking applicant pool where only one fifth of students were from underrepresented racial groups.

Notably, removing race from the AI ranking system had little to no effect on the average standardized test score of the algorithms’ selections. Furthermore, the authors found these algorithms were somewhat arbitrary, as the majority of all student applicants were high-achieving. When race data was removed and the AI system was trained with other random sets of data, the algorithm increased arbitrariness in outcomes for most student applicants.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Get the JBHE Weekly Bulletin

Receive our weekly email newsletter delivered to your inbox

Latest News

Saint Augustine’s University Will Appeal Accreditation Decision

The Southern Association of Colleges and Schools Commission on Colleges has recently voted to remove Saint Augustine's University's accreditation. The university will maintain its accreditation during the appeals process. To remain accredited, the HBCU has until February 2025 to provide evidence of its financial stability.

The Status of Black Representation in American Law School Faculty

Despite remaining far below the representation of White professors, Black law faculty are the second most represented racial group in their field. 

A Change in Leadership at Tennessee State University

Ronald Johnson, who has served as interim president of Tennessee State University for the past six monthly, has abruptly resigned his position. The university's board of trustees has appointed Dwayne Tucker, a Tennessee State University alumnus, as the new interim president of the university. He has been serving as CEO of LEAD Public Schools, a network of five charter middle and high schools in the Nashville area.

There Are Large Racial Gaps in Doctoral Awards in Specific Disciplines

African Americans earned 7.7 percent of all doctorates earned by U.S. residents and permanent residents. But Blacks are vastly underrepresented in some disciplines. For example, Blacks earned only 1.9 percent of all doctorates awarded in the geological sciences, 1.2 percent of all mathematics doctorates, 2.5 percent of all doctorates in physics, and 1.9 percent of all doctorates in astronomy.

Featured Jobs