University of Texas Affirmative Action Case Is Not Done Yet

university-of-texas-logoLast month, a panel of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the affirmative action policies on the University of Texas in a case brought by Abigail Fisher that had previously made it all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court.

In June 2013, the Supreme Court, in Fisher v. the University of Texas at Austin, reversed the decision of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals which upheld the race-sensitive admissions plan at the University of Texas at Austin. The Supreme Court ruled that the Appeals Court did not obtain sufficient information from the university as to whether the plan met the strict guidelines for a “narrowly tailored” plan as outlined in the 2003 Grutter decision. It sent the case back to the Appeal Court, ordering it to use “strict scrutiny” to determine if the university had complied with the “narrowly tailored” guidelines issued in the Grutter case. In the July decision, the Appeal Court panel said that they were “persuaded” that university had met the Grutter guidelines.

But the plaintiff was quick to respond and has now filed an appeal for the entire Fifth Circuit bench to hear the case. In the petition for rehearing, attorneys for the plaintiff stated “The Supreme Court instructed the panel to: (1) apply strict scrutiny without deference; (2) faithfully enforce the strict-scrutiny principles applicable in other settings; and (3) evaluate whether the University of Texas (“UT”) can prevail based on the existing record. The panel instead allowed UT to propose a rationale on appeal, conducted its own fact finding to support that rationale, and then deferred to UT’s assertion that pursuit of it was necessary and narrowly tailored.”

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Get the JBHE Weekly Bulletin

Receive our weekly email newsletter delivered to your inbox

Latest News

Online Articles That May Be of Interest to JBHE Readers

Each week, JBHE will provide links to online articles that may be of interest to our readers. Here are this week’s selections.

Recent Books of Interest to African American Scholars

The Journal of Blacks in Higher Education regularly publishes a list of new books that may be of interest to our readers. The books included are on a wide variety of subjects and present many different points of view.

Higher Education Gifts or Grants of Interest to African Americans

Here is this week’s news of grants or gifts to historically Black colleges and universities or for programs of particular interest to African Americans in higher education.

In Memoriam: Wendell Harris, 1940-2024

Throughout his career in education, Harris served in a wide variety of settings including K-12 schools, community colleges, and universities. He also spent several years as an administrator with the New York Department of Education.

Featured Jobs