How Bans on Affirmative Action Impact Black Student College Graduation Rates

Opponents of race-sensitive admissions programs claim that Black students are being admitted to undergraduate and graduate programs where they will be unable to compete with their White peers. As a result, many of these Black students are doomed to fail and end up dropping out.

A new paper authored by scholars at Duke University and the London School of Economics and published by the National Bureau of Economic Research examines the graduation rates of minority students before and after the ban on race-sensitive admissions at state universities in California. After the ban on race-sensitive admissions took place, Black enrollments at the most prestigious campuses of the University of California system declined significantly and have never recovered. But Black enrollment increased at other campuses of the university system. The data shows that system-wide graduation rates of minority students in fact rose by 4.4 percentage points and that the placement of Black students on campuses of California state universities where they were better able to compete was a factor in the improvement.

But the analysis found that this matching of students to the right campus of the University of California system was only responsible for 20 percent of the increase in graduation rates. The fact that admissions standards were raised (and thus many Black students were excluded who may have been admitted under a race-sensitive admissions plan) accounted for up to half the increase in graduation rates. The authors found that after the ban on race-sensitive admissions was enacted, California universities increased efforts to retain and graduate minority students, and that his accounted for between 30 and 46 percent of the increase in graduation rates.

So the so-called “mismatch theory” that claims that Black students were placed on campuses where they could not compete, really plays only a minor role in graduation rates. And it is important to note that the small increase in graduation rates does not make up for the smaller numbers of Black and other minority students who enrolled at these institutions prior to the ban on race sensitive admissions. The bottom line is that fewer Black students are gaining graduation credentials from the state university system, particularly from its most prestigious campuses.


Related Articles


  1. The fall of affirmative action type admissions has been nothing more than the advanced coming of current overt racism acts in American society. The Tea Bags and Elephant-ites agenda (since California’s Proposition 13 decades ago) is best illustrated through the images of diversity so obvious at the recent political conventions. The new face of America is with us, and it will get stronger and stronger in the election years to come. Just examine how the rise of civil rights and succreding human/ethnic equality movements are being targeted by conservative politicians. The wealthiest Americans and their loyal supporters only care about making more money and controlling the nation’s wealth! The heck with well being for everyone else. Prosperity for honest, hard working and middle class, as well as the rich, will rapidly evolve as a national priority!!! The major question should be not whether affirmative action was a good thing, but who killed it and why!

Leave a Reply

Get the JBHE Weekly Bulletin

Receive our weekly email newsletter delivered to your inbox

Latest News

Remembering the Impact of Black Women on College Basketball

As former college basketball players, we are grateful that more eyes are watching, respecting and enjoying women’s college basketball. However, we are equally troubled by the manner in which the history of women’s basketball has been inaccurately represented during the Caitlin Clark craze.

Trinity College President Joanne Berger-Sweeney Announces Retirement

In 2014, Dr. Berger-Sweeney became the first African American and first woman president of Trinity College since its founding in 1823. Over the past decade, the college has experienced growth in enrollment and graduation rates, hired more diverse faculty, and improved campus infrastructure.

Study Discovers Link Between Midlife Exposure to Racism and Risk of Dementia

Scholars at the University of Georgia, the University of Iowa, and Wake Forest University, have found an increased exposure to racial discrimination during midlife results in an increased risk for Alzheimer's disease and dementia later in life.

Josie Brown Named Dean of University of Hartford College of Arts and Sciences

Dr. Brown currently serves as a professor of English and dean of the College of Arts and Sciences at Point Park University, where she has taught courses on African American, Caribbean, and Ethnic American literature for the past two decades.

Featured Jobs