A New Academic Debate on Race and Genetics

In a recent op-ed piece in The New York Times entitled “How Genetics is Changing Our Concept of Race,” David Reich, a professor of genetics at Harvard University, argued that scientists should not disregard the genetic differences between groups of people. He notes that some groups have greater risk factors for certain diseases due to genetic differences. He takes his argument further to explore possible genetic differences in intelligence.

Writing in New York magazine, Andrew Sullivan said that Reich “carefully advanced the case that there are genetic variations between subpopulations of humans, that these are caused, as in every other species, by natural selection, and that some of these variations are not entirely superficial and do indeed overlap with our idea of race.”

In response, a group of 67 academics penned an open letter entitled “How Not to Talk About Race and Genetics.” The authors acknowledge the existence of geographically based genetic variation in our species, but they present evidence that such variation is not consistent with biological definitions of race. For example they state that “sickle cell anemia is a meaningful biological trait. In the U.S. it is commonly (and mistakenly) identified as a ‘Black’ disease. In fact, while it does have a high prevalence in populations of people with West and Central African ancestry, it also has a high prevalence in populations from much of the Arabian Peninsula, and parts of the Mediterranean and India. This is because the genetic variant that causes sickle cell is more prevalent in people descended from parts of the world with a high incidence of malaria. ‘Race’ has nothing to do with it.”

The authors of the open letter conclude by saying “we encourage geneticists to collaborate with their colleagues in the social sciences, humanities, and public health to consider more carefully how best to use racial categories in scientific research. Together, we can conduct research that will influence human lives positively.”

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Get the JBHE Weekly Bulletin

Receive our weekly email newsletter delivered to your inbox

Latest News

Jamila Taylor Named President of the Institute for Women’s Policy Research

"I am eager to set a path for IWPR that builds upon its reputation as a trusted economic and equity think tank, producing ground-breaking research and bold policy solutions that advance gender equality in ways that are meaningful and long-lasting," says Dr. Taylor.

Three African Americans Appointed to New Academic Positions

Leon Prieto, Kofi Afrifah, and Andrea Moore have been appointed to new academic positions at Clayton University, Bowie State University, and Savannah State University, respectively.

Historic HBCU Landmark Revitalized Through National Park Service Grant

Through three restoration grants totaling $2 million, the Rosenwald Practice School and Principal House will be fully restored, becoming the new home for the Northeastern North Carolina African American Research and Cultural Heritage Institute.

Five Black Leaders Appointed to Administrative Positions

Here is this week’s roundup of African American who have been appointed to new administrative positions at colleges and universities throughout the United States. If you have news for our appointments section, please email the information to contact@JBHE.com.

Featured Jobs