Study Finds That HBCUs Get Shortchanged in Traditional College Rankings

A new study led by Precious M. Hardy, a doctoral student in educational psychology at the University of Missouri, notes that historically Black colleges and universities usually do not fare well in national rankings of the best colleges and universities. But these ranking are often based on factors such as retention and graduation rates, acceptance rates, test scores of admitted students, and alumni giving rates. In short, the deck is stacked against Black colleges and universities.

This new study compared student outcomes at historically Black colleges and universities and predominantly white institutions while statistically controlling for socioeconomic status. The results showed that when comparing students from similar socioeconomic backgrounds, HBCUs outperformed predominantly WHite institutions on retention rates and salaries of graduates and had equal success in graduating their students.

The authors state that their results “suggest that HBCUs serve a higher proportion of low-income students than PWIs, which can affect the public perception of their performance. HBCUs would benefit from emphasizing their demonstrated success in promoting social mobility of students.”

Hardy is on track to earn her Ph.D. in 2021. She is a graduate of Lincoln University in Jefferson City, Missouri, where she majored in psychology.

The full study, “Below the Surface: HBCU Performance, Social Mobility, and College Ranking,” was published in the Journal of Black Studies. It may be accessed here.

Related Articles


  1. I am starting a study on the role of Grit and learning in a marketing game. It turns out that the site for this study is Morgan State University As I know very little of the Black experience, would you be willing to critque, or counsel me on my project’s literature review that deals Black Higher Education and the conditions of these institutions?

    Joseph Wolfe PhD
    University of Tulsa (IEmeritus)

Leave a Reply

Get the JBHE Weekly Bulletin

Receive our weekly email newsletter delivered to your inbox

Latest News

Three African Americans Appointed to New Academic Positions

Leon Prieto, Kofi Afrifah, and Andrea Moore have been appointed to new academic positions at Clayton University, Bowie State University, and Savannah State University, respectively.

Historic HBCU Landmark Revitalized Through National Park Service Grant

Through three restoration grants totaling $2 million, the Rosenwald Practice School and Principal House will be fully restored, becoming the new home for the Northeastern North Carolina African American Research and Cultural Heritage Institute.

Five Black Leaders Appointed to Administrative Positions

Here is this week’s roundup of African American who have been appointed to new administrative positions at colleges and universities throughout the United States. If you have news for our appointments section, please email the information to

North Carolina A&T University Establishes Research Partnership with Collins Aerospace

“There are direct relations to the research we do in the College of Engineering and the mission purpose of Collins Aerospace,” said Stephanie Luster-Teasley, interim dean of the College of Engineering at North Carolina A&T State University. “Being able to partner with Collins really gives our students the opportunities for hands-on research at each level – undergraduate and graduate.”

Featured Jobs