Report Claims Conservative Cities Do a Better Job in Educating Children From Racial and Ethnic Groups

A new report from brightbream, which bills itself as “nonprofit network of education activists demanding a better education and a brighter future for every child,” claims that schools in politically conservative cities do a better job of educating children from underrepresented racial and ethnic groups than cities that are considered politically progressive.

The study analyzed data from 12 conservative cities (such as Oklahoma City, Virginia Beach, and Jacksonville) and compared it to the data from 12 liberal cities (such as San Francisco, Washington, and Seattle) and finds the progressive cities have, on average, a 15.1 point math achievement gap for Black students and a 13.5 percent reading achievement gap for Black students.The study analyzed data from 12 conservative cities (such as Oklahoma City, Virginia Beach, and Jacksonville) and compared it to the data from 12 liberal cities

In one progressive city – San Francisco – the most progressive city in the United States, according to the report, there is an astounding 58-point achievement gap between White and Black students in mathematics. While 70 percent of White students in the city are proficient in the subject, just 12 percent of Black students are.

“Our results demonstrate that there is a negative difference between our most progressive and most conservative cities, and it can’t be explained away by factors such as city size, racial demographics, spending, poverty or income inequality,” the report states. “In cities where most of the residents identify as political progressives, educational outcomes for marginalized children lag at a greater rate than other cities.”

The report urges the progressive cities to give students from underrepresented racial and ethnic more opportunities to attend charter schools. “If progressives really want to improve education outcomes for minority students, the easiest way to do that would be to allow minority parents the opportunity to remove their children from public schools that fail to educate them and to place them in an environment where they can actually acquire a meaningful, useful education,” the report says.

The full report, The Secret Shame: How America’s Most Progressive Cities Betray Their Commitment to Educational Opportunity for All, may be downloaded here.

Related Articles


  1. This can be easily explained. Liberals have a soft bigotry of low expectations which makes excuses for why black children cannot compete on the same intellectual level as white students.

Leave a Reply

Get the JBHE Weekly Bulletin

Receive our weekly email newsletter delivered to your inbox

Latest News

Fayetteville State University Establishes Transfer Agreement with Wake Technical Community College

The new partnership will provide qualified students from Wake Technical Community College with guaranteed admission to Fayetteville State University upon completion of their associate's degree.

Three Black Scholars Taking On New Faculty Positions

The faculty appointments are James Haywood Rolling Jr. at Syracuse University in New York, Elias Towe at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh, and Roderic Pettigrew at Texas A&M University.

Howard University Receives Record-Breaking 36,000 Applicants for Class of 2028

The class of 2028 applicant pool at Howard University increased by 4,000 applications compared to last year's class of 2027. This year, the university's acceptance rate was roughly 31 percent, down five percentage points from last year.

Laquala Dixon Honored by National Association of Student Personnel Administrators for Service as HBCU Liaison

A member of the NASPA since 2013, Dr. Dixon was honored with the 2024 Sankofa Award for her commitment and contributions to the organization as the HBCU liaison for the Black Diaspora Knowledge Community.

Featured Jobs