For Young White Children, Language Trumps Race in Defining an Adult’s Identity

In an interesting experiment conducted at the University of Chicago, children ages 5 and 6, were shown video images and vocal recordings of a child and two adults. The children were asked, “Which adult will the child grow up to be?” In the images shown to the children, one adult matched the racial appearance of the child. The other adult matched the language spoken by the child. In no instance did the adults match both the child’s language and racial appearance.

White children ages 5 and 6 were more likely to say the child in the video image would grow up to be the adult who spoke the same language rather than the adult who appeared to be of the same race. Katherine Kinzler, an assistant professor of psychology at the University of Chicago and the lead author of the research article, stated language can be more important than race in guiding young white children’s social preferences for others.

But when African American children were given the same test, they tended to say that the child would grow up to be more like the adult of the same race rather than the adult who spoke the same language as the child. Jocelyn Dautel, a graduate student who is co-author of the study, said, “Children of different racial groups may have different experiences with race as a meaningful social category, which could contribute to their performance.”

For 10-year-old children given the same test, both Whites and Blacks tended to choose the adult who had the same racial appearance as the child.

The research was published in the journal Developmental Science.

Related Articles


  1. Based on the premise that children are taught racism, the results of this experiment are predictable. Unless a 5 or 6 year old is growing up in a bi-lingual and/or multi-racial home, it would seem reasonable that the child is going to identify with the adult whose speech they understand. Initially children do not see people racially. They see them simply as people until some adult or experience brings to their attention that there are “differences.” Physical characteristics vary from one person to another with no physical characteristic having higher value than any other unless we are taught and society assigns a higher value or underscores differences.

    By the age of ten most children have learned racial differences and the social attitudes associated with those differences.

    It is neither mystery nor revelation that “Children of different racial groups[may] have different experiences with race as a meaningful social category . . .” The performance, attitudes, and behaviors, not only of children, but of most who have been socialized in the United States are reflected in what is recognized as either racism or the effects of racism. Call it what you will in your erudite studies.

Leave a Reply

Get the JBHE Weekly Bulletin

Receive our weekly email newsletter delivered to your inbox

Latest News

The Official Poverty Rate for African Americans Is the Lowest in History

The bad news is that In 2022, the Black poverty rate was still more than double to rate for non-Hispanic Whites. In 2022, 22.3 percent of all Black children lived in poverty.

Berenecea Johnson Eanes Will Be the Next President of California State University, Los Angeles

Since 2020, Dr. Eanes has served as president of York College of the City University of New York. She served as vice president for student affairs at California State University, Fullerton from 2012 to 2019. She will begin her new job in January.

Prior to the Pandemic, White Children Were Three Times as Likely to Be Homeschool Than Black Children

In 2019, Some 4 percent of all White children were homeschooled, compared to 1.2 percent of Black children. Thus, Whites were more than three times as likely as Blacks to be homeschooled. The most commonly reported reasons for homeschooling were concern about the school environment.

Two Black Scholars Who Have Been Appointed to University Provost Positions

Nosa O. Egiebor is the new provost and executive vice chancellor at Montana Technological University in Butte and Toni Williams has been named provost and executive vice president of academic affairs at Martin University in Indianapolis.

Featured Jobs