University Study Examines How Racial Bias Seeps Into Jury Deliberations

scales_of_justiceA study by researchers at the University of California, Irvine and the University of California, Santa Cruz finds that White men tend to be the most influential figures in jury deliberations. The fact that White men are influential figures on juries may result in harsher sentences for Black male defendants.

The researchers conducted a series of 100 mock jury trial deliberations. The facts in all the cases were the same. But the race of the victim and the defendant varied. The researchers found that in these mock trial deliberations:

  • White men were the most likely to be elected jury foremen.
  • White men were more likely than others to argue forcefully for their position.
  • White male jurors were more likely to empathize with White defendants than minority defendants.
  • White male jurors were likely to discount mitigating factors in cases involving Black defendants than so than in cases involving White defendants.

The authors observed that “in the present analysis, we found that White male jurors often asserted emotional authority in the deliberations in two distinct ways: first in terms of asserting their own emotional responses and, second, by policing the emotional expressions of others. Moreover, this authority appeared to be deployed differentially as a function of the defendant’s race.”

The article, “Emotion, Authority, and Death: (Raced) Negotiations in Mock Capital Jury Deliberations,” was published on the website of the journal Law & Social Inquiry, a publication of the American Bar Foundation. It is available here.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Get the JBHE Weekly Bulletin

Receive our weekly email newsletter delivered to your inbox

Latest News

Higher Education Gifts or Grants of Interest to African Americans

Here is this week’s news of grants or gifts to historically Black colleges and universities or for programs of particular interest to African Americans in higher education.

Three African Americans Appointed to Leadership Positions in Diversity

The three African Americans appointed to diversity positions are Melanie Duckworth at the University of Nevada Reno, Doug Thompson at the University of Notre Dame, and Anthony Jones at Centre College in Kentucky.

Tuajuanda Jordan to Retire From the Presidency of St. Mary’s College of Maryland

Dr. Jordan has led St. Mary's College of Maryland for the past 10 years. She has previously held faculty and leadership positions with Xavier University of Louisiana, Howard Hughes Medical Institute, and Lewis & Clark College.

The White House Releases Report on “The Economics of HBCUs”

The report found that although HBCUs account for less than 3 percent of all higher education institutions in the United States, they have 8 percent of all Black undergraduate student enrollments and produce 13 percent of all bachelor's degrees earned by Black students.

Featured Jobs